Title: Scorsese’s “Killers of the Flower Moon” Sparks Debate Over Authenticity of Native American Portrayals
Hollywood has long been criticized for perpetuating stereotypes and promoting the White savior narrative when it comes to portraying Native American characters. However, Martin Scorsese’s upcoming film, “Killers of the Flower Moon,” based on the true story of the Osage murders in the 1920s, has taken a different approach. Despite initial skepticism from the Osage people, Scorsese and his team worked closely with the Osage Nation to ensure an authentic depiction of their history and culture.
The Osage Nation, concerned about the potential misrepresentation of their people, expressed their worries to Scorsese. In response, the renowned director and his team met with Osage Nation Chief Geoffrey Standing Bear and residents of the Gray Horse community, who are descendants of the Osage murder victims. The meeting aimed to establish trust and address any concerns held by the Osage community.
Former Osage Nation Chief Jim Gray, who holds a personal connection to the story, played a crucial role in urging Scorsese to tell the story from an Osage perspective. As a result, the script underwent significant changes, shifting the focus to the relationship between Mollie Burkhart, an Osage woman, and her White settler husband, Ernest Burkhart. This change aimed to emphasize the Osage experience within the narrative.
Despite the effort to provide a more accurate portrayal of the Osage people, some members of the community criticized the film for centering primarily on a White man and questioned the depiction of the marriage. However, the involvement of countless Osage consultants and tribe members in the film’s production aimed to ensure authenticity.
Osage consultants worked diligently alongside the film’s crew to incorporate the Osage language, traditional clothing, and scenery from the Osage reservation. Christopher Cรดtรฉ, an Osage language consultant, praised Scorsese’s commitment to representation but expressed reservations regarding the portrayal of Mollie and Burkhart’s marriage.
Nevertheless, the overall authenticity of the film, particularly in terms of language and cultural details, impressed the Osage people involved in its production. They hope that “Killers of the Flower Moon” will set a new industry standard for accurate and respectful representations of Native cultures and inspire Hollywood to follow suit.
In conclusion, Scorsese’s “Killers of the Flower Moon” has sparked a necessary debate about the representation of Native Americans in Hollywood. While the film demonstrates significant efforts to portray the Osage people accurately, it remains subject to criticism. Nonetheless, the collaboration between the film’s team and the Osage community symbolizes a step toward encouraging authentic and inclusive storytelling in the film industry.
“Prone to fits of apathy. Devoted music geek. Troublemaker. Typical analyst. Alcohol practitioner. Food junkie. Passionate tv fan. Web expert.”